Milburn review reflects Manchester Met findings on barriers facing NEET young people
Government review echoes findings from landmark study into barriers facing young people at risk of becoming NEET
A major government review published today (November 17) into the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) has reinforced findings from a landmark Manchester Met study which found that many young people face significant barriers to work, training and education long before they become economically inactive.
The review comes as almost one million young people are currently classified as NEET and sets out a 10-year ambition to reduce the proportion to around 5%, alongside a package of reforms designed to improve participation in education, training and employment.
Today’s final review, led by Alan Milburn, sets out recommendations aimed at improving opportunities for young people with a view to supporting more into employment, education and training. Central to the proposals are a new Opportunity Guarantee, giving every young person a route into education, training or work, and a Support Guarantee providing access to employment, health and practical support.
Researchers behind Manchester Met’s Mapping Interventions for Young People ‘at risk’ of Becoming NEET in England (MINE) project say the review reflects their research evidence that tackling youth unemployment requires more than welfare reform alone, and that lasting change depends on addressing the underlying barriers many young people face throughout their schooling experience.
Several of the review’s key conclusions echo findings from the five-year MINE study, including the importance of mental health support, joined-up services, effective careers guidance and sustained support through key educational transitions.
The five-year MINE study found that young people who become NEET are often portrayed as lacking motivation or aspiration, when in reality many face complex structural barriers that make successful transitions into adulthood more difficult. These can include poor mental health, unmet support needs, disrupted educational experiences, fragmented support services and limited access to opportunities that reflect their individual circumstances.
The research found that many young people want to continue learning, find meaningful work and build positive futures for themselves, but are frequently let down by systems that fail to provide joined-up support at key transition points in their lives.
Lisa Russell, Professor of Education and Employment in Manchester Met’s Institute for Children’s Futures and lead researcher for the MINE project, said: “We welcome the Milburn review’s focus on creating better opportunities for young people and supporting more of them into education, employment and training. Our research shows that most young people want exactly that, but many face barriers that are outside their control.
“Young people do not suddenly become disconnected at age16 or 18. For many, the challenges have developed over a number of years and can include poor mental health, disrupted education, unmet support needs or difficult and sometimes repetitive experiences of education and training.
“The evidence from our research shows that the quality of support matters. Providing opportunities is important, but those opportunities need to be accessible, inclusive and responsive to young people’s individual circumstances if they are to make a meaningful difference. Support needs to be sustained across different transition points.”
The MINE project identified concerns around support available to young people during key transition periods, particularly during and after Year 11, as well as policies and practices that can unintentionally restrict progression routes for those who do not manage to pass their GCSEs and follow traditional educational pathways. Researchers found that systems often place significant emphasis on a narrow set of academic outcomes, despite young people having diverse needs, strengths and ambitions.
The study also highlighted inconsistencies in careers guidance, fragmented support services and the importance of sustained trusted relationships in helping young people remain engaged with education, training and employment. Researchers argue that addressing systemic barriers, rather than placing responsibility solely on individuals, is essential to improving outcomes.
The research calls for a greater focus on the quality of prevention delivery, bespoke intervention and stronger coordination between schools, colleges, employers and support services to help young people navigate increasingly complex education and employment systems.
Prof Russell added: “Lasting change requires more than welfare reform alone. Alongside employment support, we need less rigidity and focus on GCSE outcomes in secondary schools, improved mental health provision and stronger support for young people whose needs have too often gone unrecognised.
“An ‘opportunity guarantee’ or ‘support guarantee’ as recommended by Milburn can only succeed if the opportunities themselves are genuinely inclusive, supportive and responsive to young people’s needs.”
Funded by the Leverhulme Trust, the MINE project has produced a series of reports and policy recommendations designed to support policymakers and practitioners working to improve outcomes for young people across England.
The findings contribute to a growing body of evidence calling for a more joined-up approach to supporting young people at risk of becoming NEET, including evidence given by Prof Russell to the House of Lords Social Mobility Policy Committee.